Directors and Film Composers: Collaboration
April 30th, 2012People have often told me that my [wind band] music sounds very “cinematic,” and then they almost always follow up with, “why don’t you write music for movies?” If only it were that easy!
Frankly, I don’t think I’d be very good at it — the long hours, the grueling schedule, the cutting room floor — I tend to like my 8 hours of sleep and my music has become really personal to me that I definitely wouldn’t want it on any floor. There are lot of composers who specifically study film scoring at places like USC or Berklee or UCLA (my friend and fellow composer, Vinny Oppido, happens to be AMAZING at it), and these composers live in media hotspots like Los Angeles where all the significant work is and where all the important people are. You probably can’t learn to surf in Mechanicsville, Iowa — you’ve got to be where the beaches are.
One of the things that has always turned me off about film/tv composing is that in movies (and particularly in television dramas), music is often used primarily as an ambience and emotional soundscapes. I’m not saying this is a bad thing at all because music absolutely has a place and when music and visuals marry like this, music should absolutely respect its place (often) in the background. For me, however, I like writing music that is dramatic, often in the foreground, which is why I love writing concert music. In a concert hall, the music, itself, is the main event. This means that I can go crazy with it and do whatever I want because no one, other than me, is telling me what or how to write.
Again, I’m not saying I don’t like writing music for film — I’m saying that the concert music world and the commercial film music world require two very different mind sets. One of the most important elements in the film music mindset is the collaborative mindset.
Collaboration is such a powerful tool to help make big ideas even bigger and better than they would/could/should ever individually be. (Author Jonah Lehrer even structured the second half of his book, Imagine: How Creativity Works, dedicated to understanding successful collaborations). Composers often like to think of working on a film as a “collaboration” — especially if the composer is young and the filmmakers don’t have much of a budget to pay said composer. But the reality is that it’s not a true collaboration in that, according to auteur theory, the director ultimately has creative control and gets the majority credit for the overall creative “vision.” So for composers, this means that the most important thing we have to do is to attempt, with all our might, to get into the director’s head as soon as possible. If we composers are not on the same creative page as the director, we could end up wasting a lot of time and effort writing music cues that might ultimately have to be completely rewritten or perhaps not be used at all.
Scary, right? No, not really — that’s just how the world of film music works.
Again, I’m totally not anti-film projects. I actually love collaborating on these different projects from time to time. One of my favorite collaborations to date, Voyage Trekkers, (which I’ve written about before) has been an immensely gratifying experience. Even recently I was asked to sequence a short orchestral score to a trailer for the Gaudioso Twins’ film, Duke. You can view the trailer to their film on the front page of the movie’s website. Even though it took me a rough 4 or 5 tries before the final music cue fit the tone of the film and matched the director’s vision, the ability to wade through these rejections is what I think is absolutely essential to being a successful film composer, even on a small scale. If you, as a composer, accept this mindset and are willing to give (and give up) your best work for the best interests of the project, I think it is absolutely possible to have a successful collaboration that everyone can be proud to own.
















